Page 1 of 1
HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainless
Posted: Sat Apr 13, 2013 7:21 pm
by jrc413
Heres the situation, Im new to the board and to tig welding and have no one around to help me in person. I just got a Lincoln precision tig 225 and my first stainless project is some parkerizing tanks made of 16ga 304 stainless sheet. I bent them up and "just" have to weld on the 8"x8" end caps. There is multiple problems but Im just trying to make this work and learn from it and looking for any advice. I havent been using any filler and its gone ok 3/4 of the time but here and there I'll do a stretch that just will not keep from creating holes and wont join. What are my options for fixing the problem areas without making the holes bigger and making the problem worse. I just need the freakin thing to hold liquid and not leak.
Current settings:
45-50amps
5-pps pulse rate
1/16" 2% thoriated tungsten
No. 7 cup ( biggest Ive got)
15 cfh
Ive been able to do some "decent" welds with mild steel and alum, but this stuff is kicking my butt! Any advice is much appreciated. Thanks
- tig1.JPG (91.49 KiB) Viewed 4363 times
- tig2.JPG (87.39 KiB) Viewed 4363 times
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sat Apr 13, 2013 7:42 pm
by Otto Nobedder
This is a case where 308 MIG wire (.035 or .045) makes excellent filler.
1/16" TIG rod will quench your puddle at those amps.
You can feed 308 MIG wire quickly without chilling your puddle.
Steve S
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 3:48 am
by Markus
Low amperes and clean material. I would also try to purge it, if possible. It does help on stainless and with purge you can prevent creating holes quite well.
Markus
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 4:58 am
by foamballer
Yes definitely clean the edges. Are you able to get a hand inside the tank? If so, feed your filler rod from the back side and arc up right on the tip of the filler. Do little sections at a time.
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 5:37 am
by Alexa
Foamballer.
I am enjoying pondering the feeding from the backside suggestion.
Tanks.
Alexa
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 9:00 am
by Fat Bob
Alexa wrote:Foamballer.
I am enjoying pondering the feeding from the backside suggestion.
Tanks.
Alexa
Hummmm, me too. If you guys smell smoke it's just me thinking about this.
Foamballer, how about a little more info or better yet a picture or two.
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 12:55 pm
by WerkSpace
TORCH CONTROL
When I first learned how to oxy/acetylene weld,
I practiced by purposely burning holes in metal and then patching the holes.
This taught me torch control better than any other method. I got really good at patching holes.
So, when I transitioned to TIG welding, I had torch control down to a science.
The only difference was that I was now using an electric flame instead of a gas flame.
My advice is simple...
1. Get some scrap metal.
2. Purposely burn holes in it.
3. Learn how to patch the holes.
...your problem is nothing more than learning how to control the torch. Don't watch the torch, watch the metal...
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 2:21 pm
by Alexa
Jrc413.
In tig welding in contrast to stick welding, the diameter/thickness of the filler metal can change independently of the amperage. This allows for 'melting off' the filler with low amperage. Almost a simulation of slow motion during the deposit.
Alexa
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 4:26 pm
by jrc413
Thanks for all the tips and advice, I just found some .035 stainless mig wire that I forgot about and Im going to give that try on some scrap pieces. Am I in the ballpark as far as amps go if Im using that thin mig filler wire? Thanks again
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 5:19 pm
by Otto Nobedder
You should be able to weld that 16 ga. as low as 35 amps (though you may be more comfortable a bit higher... Kind of a preference issue) and still have no problem feeding .035 filler when needed.
It may take longer to establish the initial puddle, but since heat move so slow in stainless compare to carbon steel, once you have enough heat to establish the puddle, it'll hold enough heat to move along just fine.
I've said before, no two of us do it quite alike, so take all advice for what it's worth. Some may not work for you at all, and some may need to be adjusted to fit your style.
Steve S
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Sun Apr 14, 2013 5:25 pm
by Otto Nobedder
One other tip: LOTS of tacks. That 16 ga flexes easy, and the heat from your weld will open the gap, leading to keyholing, wich is the enemy of a fillerless weld. I'd tack every inch to inch and a half for that outside corner, then weld tack-to-tack moving around a lot, to let each weld cool before welding near it again.
Steve S
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Thu Apr 18, 2013 3:15 am
by foamballer
Fat Bob wrote:Alexa wrote:Foamballer.
I am enjoying pondering the feeding from the backside suggestion.
Tanks.
Alexa
Hummmm, me too. If you guys smell smoke it's just me thinking about this.
Foamballer, how about a little more info or better yet a picture or two.
Are you guys for real? these are the two most disturbing posts I've read for quite a while
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Thu Apr 18, 2013 6:27 am
by weldin mike 27
Hey,
Dont forget the penetration . Welding ....... such a rude rude trade.
Mick
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Thu Apr 18, 2013 6:06 pm
by Otto Nobedder
Foamballer,
You'd be surprised how few folk are familiar with backfeeding a weld. It's a lot more common in the pipe trades than a typical job-shop, or home garage.
I can't do it worth a crap, myself, because I've needed it so rarely.
Steve S
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Wed Nov 19, 2014 7:03 am
by Ritchie
Hi to all who posted a reply to this post.
I have posted almost same on other welding forums and no one responded.
I will be trying out the techniques/advise soon.
A big thanks from me.
Best Regards from Scotland
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Wed Nov 19, 2014 10:23 am
by dsmabe
- 20141020_115901.jpg (26.32 KiB) Viewed 2942 times
I did this one, 20ga 304, mostly no filler. Used aluminum angle for backing and made sure everything was very tight on the fit up. If the fit up was loose or you got going too fast it's easy to have the problems your having. Since you already have holes, I would use copper to back the weld and just go carefully.
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Wed Nov 19, 2014 6:01 pm
by RonMartens
don't laugh, you can use 3/16 or 1/4 flex copper tube that fits in the corner, just wrap it with aluminum foil to conform to the corner and clamp it or use HVAC foil tape.. the foil tape will leave a mark ..
your local welding supply should have a backer tape for thin stainless.. it's pretty common.
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Thu Nov 20, 2014 11:30 am
by Rick_H
WerkSpace wrote:TORCH CONTROL
When I first learned how to oxy/acetylene weld,
I practiced by purposely burning holes in metal and then patching the holes.
This taught me torch control better than any other method. I got really good at patching holes.
So, when I transitioned to TIG welding, I had torch control down to a science.
The only difference was that I was now using an electric flame instead of a gas flame.
My advice is simple...
1. Get some scrap metal.
2. Purposely burn holes in it.
3. Learn how to patch the holes.
...your problem is nothing more than learning how to control the torch. Don't watch the torch, watch the metal...
Agreed 100%.... If you can master torch control you can do anything, the above method is how I taught myself how to fill holes years ago. Now when I have a repair job holes or gaps don't worry me one bit. I also use mig wire or .035" fill rod on thin stainless. Pulse is a great tool bit I'd try to master without it first.... Learn what to look for, read the puddle and metal
Re: HELP! trying to fill "blow through gaps" in thin stainle
Posted: Thu Nov 20, 2014 11:30 am
by Rick_H
WerkSpace wrote:TORCH CONTROL
When I first learned how to oxy/acetylene weld,
I practiced by purposely burning holes in metal and then patching the holes.
This taught me torch control better than any other method. I got really good at patching holes.
So, when I transitioned to TIG welding, I had torch control down to a science.
The only difference was that I was now using an electric flame instead of a gas flame.
My advice is simple...
1. Get some scrap metal.
2. Purposely burn holes in it.
3. Learn how to patch the holes.
...your problem is nothing more than learning how to control the torch. Don't watch the torch, watch the metal...
Agreed 100%.... If you can master torch control you can do anything, the above method is how I taught myself how to fill holes years ago. Now when I have a repair job holes or gaps don't worry me one bit. I also use mig wire or .035" fill rod on thin stainless. Pulse is a great tool bit I'd try to master without it first.... Learn what to look for, read the puddle and metal