Scotsman asks which welder for thin stainless steel sheet
Posted: Thu Aug 29, 2013 4:32 pm
I've done a bit of gas oxy-acetylene welding years ago. I was doing DIY repairs to my car rusty-sheet-metal body-work, bought the O/A kit and taught myself how to use it, after a fashion. The welds were OK for my purpose at the time but in no way "invisible", in no way forming a smooth join between sheets.
Now, what I really like to be able to do is to be able to make very high quality, professional looking and strong "invisible" butt welds in stainless steel sheet, oh say around 0.8mm to 1.0mm (0.031" to 0.039") thick. For my new application, not car body work this time, thicker welds, lap joints, etc, just won't do. This time, I need to not exceed the sheet thickness in the weld because I need to have it go smoothly through a bead roller and a thicker weld would cause problems through the rollers.
So not knowing how to do this "invisible" welding, I googled "invisible welding" and found this video on YouTube of what I think is TIG - Tungsten-Inert-Gas pulsed welding -
wntAnn4EowM
This video also features on a welding tips and tricks webpage here. Most informative. Thank you.
I was impressed by the smooth, apparently seamless weld to the extent that you are not quite sure where the weld line is, certainly better looking than I could ever do with my oxy-acetylene gas torch. Then again, I was not trying to do "invisible" welding at the time. Perhaps it is possible with O/A kit?
I can't tell how strong that guy's invisible weld is but it certainly looks good.
Now I want to buy equipment that can do that and see if I can learn to use it properly.
So my first question is - is a pulsed TIG welding machine the best generic type of welding kit to buy for my application - "invisible" welds in sheet stainless steel? If not, what is better kind of kit to buy?
From the welding tips and tricks page
My second question is what maker would you recommend to buy (bearing in mind I am buying in Scotland / Britain / UK and I want to buy locally from what is easily available here)?
For example, I am looking at SIP right now because my local tool shop sells those and I asked them about this product they offer.
SIP 05268 Weldmate P188HF TIG / ARC Inverter Welder With Pulse
Would that be suitable for my purposes?
My local shop also offers the Sealey line of TIG welding kit, which seem to be lighter but don't seem to mention the "pulse" facility, so I am wondering if those ones are not so suitable. Do I really need pulse?
I gather that I would need a AC-TIG if I ever wanted to weld aluminium but the issue with the SIP products there is the SIP welder with AC/DC TIG and pulsed is a lot more expensive. Whereas the DC only with pulse might cost me around £450 , the AC/DC TIG with pulse would be more like a whopping £1,300. It also weighs in at a hefty 26Kg to lug about.
So I am tempted to sacrifice the aluminium welding and save £850 and my back muscles by opting for the DC only TIG with pulse but if there was another make that offered what I need for my invisible welding plus an aluminium weld capability at a more affordable price, I'd like to know about that now.
So am I on the right lines for what to buy and what would you recommend? Thanks!
Now, what I really like to be able to do is to be able to make very high quality, professional looking and strong "invisible" butt welds in stainless steel sheet, oh say around 0.8mm to 1.0mm (0.031" to 0.039") thick. For my new application, not car body work this time, thicker welds, lap joints, etc, just won't do. This time, I need to not exceed the sheet thickness in the weld because I need to have it go smoothly through a bead roller and a thicker weld would cause problems through the rollers.
So not knowing how to do this "invisible" welding, I googled "invisible welding" and found this video on YouTube of what I think is TIG - Tungsten-Inert-Gas pulsed welding -
wntAnn4EowM
This video also features on a welding tips and tricks webpage here. Most informative. Thank you.
I was impressed by the smooth, apparently seamless weld to the extent that you are not quite sure where the weld line is, certainly better looking than I could ever do with my oxy-acetylene gas torch. Then again, I was not trying to do "invisible" welding at the time. Perhaps it is possible with O/A kit?
I can't tell how strong that guy's invisible weld is but it certainly looks good.
Now I want to buy equipment that can do that and see if I can learn to use it properly.
So my first question is - is a pulsed TIG welding machine the best generic type of welding kit to buy for my application - "invisible" welds in sheet stainless steel? If not, what is better kind of kit to buy?
From the welding tips and tricks page
Though the author differs with the welder in the video as to the ideal pulse frequency nevertheless he too seems to be recommending "pulse TIG" as opposed to non-pulsed TIG, right?pulse tig is used to weld. You can count the pulses and its exactly 3pps or 3 pulses per second. Personally, I hate to weld with low frequency pulsing like this. It drives me nuts. I much prefer to set the pulse frequency to around 30 pps. That way my eyes do not have time to adjust between pulses. You still get the benefit of reduced heat input and agitation of the weld puddle without the eye strain and headache.
My second question is what maker would you recommend to buy (bearing in mind I am buying in Scotland / Britain / UK and I want to buy locally from what is easily available here)?
For example, I am looking at SIP right now because my local tool shop sells those and I asked them about this product they offer.
SIP 05268 Weldmate P188HF TIG / ARC Inverter Welder With Pulse
Would that be suitable for my purposes?
My local shop also offers the Sealey line of TIG welding kit, which seem to be lighter but don't seem to mention the "pulse" facility, so I am wondering if those ones are not so suitable. Do I really need pulse?
I gather that I would need a AC-TIG if I ever wanted to weld aluminium but the issue with the SIP products there is the SIP welder with AC/DC TIG and pulsed is a lot more expensive. Whereas the DC only with pulse might cost me around £450 , the AC/DC TIG with pulse would be more like a whopping £1,300. It also weighs in at a hefty 26Kg to lug about.
So I am tempted to sacrifice the aluminium welding and save £850 and my back muscles by opting for the DC only TIG with pulse but if there was another make that offered what I need for my invisible welding plus an aluminium weld capability at a more affordable price, I'd like to know about that now.
So am I on the right lines for what to buy and what would you recommend? Thanks!